I'm a perfectionist, which is actually a great deal for you! These products are made with the usual high-quality ingredients as all my other products, but they have slight imperfections for one reason or another. Imperfections range from a knick in the salve due to the lid hitting it, cracks in the salve due to a misshaped tin, dented tins, a smudge on the label, etc. While they are not up to our standards for gift-giving, they would be wonderful for personal use and are great deal!